It's... really bad.
Like, it's so bad I'm not sure I can convey in mere words. Let's go to the points system:
- Sightly Better Sprouse is still kind of darling, and Slightly Worse Sprouse has actually improved somewhat! +2
- Brenda Song is still incredibly adorable! +1
- Somehow, though, they've removed everything endearing about London -- she was always shallow and dumb, but mostly oblivious and not selfish. Now she's just horrible on every level. -2
- Cody is still adorably, awkwardly gay, barely subtextually gay. +1
- Zach is still really, incredibly, extraordinarily hateful. -1
- Carrie has been written off! Thank. God. +1
- She's been replaced by an awful wacky teacher, who is somehow a worse actress, and more annoying. -1
- No Ashley Tisdale to hold the show together by falling down a lot. -5
- No Arwin or Esteban. Who knew I liked them until they were gone? -1
- The old mediocre peripheral characters gone, replaced by entirely new mediocre peripheral characters. 0
- The occasional actually amusing, well-delivered line: +1
- Moseby! Oh, come on. He's always been the best thing about the Suite Life. +2
- The Suite Life continues its tradition of plenty of farting, burping, and pooping jokes. -1k
- All the sexism from the original Suite Life made the jump to sea. -1million
- Plus a heaping helping of racism, with potential for plenty more as the twins explore wacky foreign cultures! -1bajillion
...Like I said. It wasbad. Why can't we just have a wacky show where Brenda, SBS, and Phil Lewis (Moseby) hang out being endearing? I'd watch that!